At first my research came up short, at least I thought it did, but actually it ended up being helpful. It turned out the similar phone number with the last 4 digits was the same company calling me because the do not call service that another blog comment suggested worked for this phone number too. Just call 866-246-7196, give the calling phone number and the receiving phone number to be added to the do not call list.
(201) 243-3414 | +1 2012433414 Phone Number Reports
+1 201-243-3414 Phone Call Reports
Candice - Sep 9, 2013 07:44 PM
Anonymous - Aug 29, 2013 09:40 AM
when pressing any number to be added to no call list, as instructed, get hung up on..
Caller: Vehicle Warranty
You might be interested in checking reports for numbers
Other phone numbers in the +1 201 area code